By EBV staff writer
The National Bank of Ethiopia’s (NBE) recent foreign currency auctions have delivered starkly contrasting outcomes, prompting financial sector observers to question the accuracy of market signals and the central bank’s grasp of genuine demand dynamics.

A special auction on February 21 saw the central bank make $500 million available to commercial lenders, yet $44.7 million of that allocation went unsubscribed, with bids collectively reaching just $455.3 million. Industry veterans characterized this undersubscription as exceptional within Ethiopia’s auction framework.
The result stood in sharp contrast to the prevailing narrative of acute forex scarcity that has long characterized the economy. Analysts scrambled for explanations, with theories ranging from potential liquidity crunches among banks to fundamental questions about why demand would falter in an environment where hard currency is traditionally heavily oversubscribed.
The mystery deepened barely a week and a half later. At the standard fortnightly auction conducted March 3, the NBE made $70 million available. This time, lenders submitted requests totaling $177 million—more than double the offered sum, illustrating dramatically different market behavior in a compressed timeframe.
Tilahun Girma, a consultant with I Xcel Financial, Management, and IT Consultation Company, noted that while liquidity concerns were predictable, the central bank’s immediate focus remains containing price volatility.
“Short-term price management is the central bank’s primary concern until organic supply-demand equilibrium emerges,” he explained. However, he raised doubts about whether the NBE currently possesses adequate analytical tools to precisely quantify foreign currency requirements across the economy.
Eshetu Fantaye, a seasoned banking professional and former bank president, highlighted how absent market transparency complicates interpretation of these contradictory auction performances.
“Confirming liquidity constraints as the cause requires concrete data,” Eshetu said. “A prudent bank leader would maintain sufficient reserves in settlement accounts specifically for auction participation. Without comprehensive information, we cannot definitively attribute the February 21 shortfall to liquidity limitations.”
The fundamental question troubling analysts: Why would financial institutions leave any portion of a central bank forex offering unpurchased if genuine dollar shortages persist?
A senior international banking department manager at a mid-tier commercial bank proposed that the $44.7 million surplus might suggest temporary easing of market pressure, potentially linked to recent currency injections that diminished speculative hoarding.
Eshetu emphasized that properly diagnosing such patterns demands consolidated visibility into letters of credit and forex requisitions across all 32 commercial banks operating in the country.
“This aggregate figure remains unknown—nobody is compiling it,” he noted, pointing to a critical intelligence gap obscuring actual market conditions.
His projections suggest Ethiopia requires between $4 billion and $6 billion over the coming 12-18 months to satisfy genuine currency demands.
“Substantial early-stage market injection during reform implementation could effectively moderate expectations, curtail speculation, and normalize demand patterns,” he argued.
Both Eshetu and banking sources interviewed by Capital underscored the urgency of enhanced information infrastructure and market surveillance capabilities. Eshetu proposed a centralized digital platform aggregating forex supply and demand data across institutions, enabling regulators to formulate more accurate market assessments.
“Without such mechanisms, the forex market will continue generating ambiguous, potentially misleading indicators,” he cautioned.
While individual banks track client-driven currency needs and trade finance obligations internally, the absence of consolidated industry visibility perpetuates market opacity, according to Eshetu.
Bankers additionally warned that continued uncertainty could exacerbate parallel market pressures. Although the black market rate temporarily stabilized following the February 21 auction, it has reportedly resumed upward movement after the March 3 sale exposed demand substantially exceeding official supply.
Eshetu also identified the Ethiopian Petroleum Supply Enterprise as a significant demand driver, noting that institutions handling its transactions process substantial fuel import payments.
He observed that the birr’s 1.2 percent appreciation following February’s auction may have encouraged stronger March participation, though the currency reportedly softened again post-sale.
Tilahun characterized selective intervention as characteristic of economic transition periods, particularly during exchange rate liberalization phases.
“The NBE’s motivation—near-term market stabilization—must be understood contextually. Such intervention typifies early floating exchange rate implementation, consistent with international transition experiences,” he said.
Banks typically determine auction participation based on letter of credit portfolios and client demand, information theoretically accessible to regulators through established reporting channels, Tilahun added.
He acknowledged, however, that auction volatility inevitably incorporates speculative elements, particularly given blind bidding processes where institutions cannot observe competitors’ offers.
“Forex price fluctuation will continue responding to demand patterns,” Tilahun concluded, emphasizing that durable stability ultimately requires policies addressing fundamental inflationary pressures and structural currency supply-demand misalignments.©SECO


